Episode 37: A Mother’s Quest – The Murder of Mike Williams
In our latest episode of Super SUS, we delve into the mysterious disappearance of Jerry Michael “Mike” Williams, a successful real estate appraiser from Florida whose absence ignited a sprawling investigation. What initially seemed a routine duck-hunting trip quickly escalates into a suspenseful journey filled with betrayal, secrets…and far more than meets the eye.
🦆 Disappearance on Lake Seminole
On December 16, 2000, Mike left early for a hunting trip on Lake Seminole, promising to return by noon—to mark a personal milestone with his wife, Denise. But when the day ended without him coming home, a massive search began. His boat was found with shotgun and decoys aboard, but Mike himself—and a host of crucial details—were missing.
👩👧 A Mother's Relentless Fight
Mike’s mother, Cheryl Williams, refused to accept a simple explanation. She tirelessly pursued answers—writing letters, contacting officials, and pushing for renewed investigation. Her dedication kept the case alive and uncovered layers that might have otherwise been overlooked.
💸 Intrigue, Money & Murky Motives
As investigators dug deeper, financial arrangements and personal relationships came into question. Life insurance policies, longtime friendships, and personal ties formed a web of possibilities, each more unsettling than the last.
🎯 Trust, Suspicion & Hidden Mysteries
What began as a search-and-rescue story morphed into something far more complex. As paths crossed and loyalties shifted, the case revealed darker undertones—challenging everything we thought we knew about the people involved.
🔍 Why You Should Tune In
A captivating true story that keeps you guessing
A mother’s emotional quest for answers
Twists and turns that refuse to play by the rules
If you're drawn to true crime that unfolds like a thriller—building tension, deepening mysteries, and introducing shocking questions—this episode of Super SUS is your next listen. Join us as we chase the unanswered and reveal the truths lurking beneath the surface.
