Episode 40: A Family Affair – The Murders of Billie Jean Hayworth and Billy Payne

In our most recent episode of Super SUS, we delve into the unsettling series of events that led to a horrific double murder, all wrapped in a chilling tale of deception, manipulation, and betrayal. Join us as we explore the tragic story of Billie Jean Hayworth and Billy Payne, a young couple whose lives were cut short by a deadly web of lies.

The Victims

Billie Jean Hayworth and Billy Payne appeared to have it all—a shared love of flea markets, fishing, and life’s simple pleasures. Their world seemed perfect, especially with the arrival of their son, Tyler, in 2011. But Tyler's life took an unimaginable turn when he lost both parents to a brutal crime. As we peel back the layers, we see how their once vibrant lives were overshadowed by the darkness that ended them far too soon.

The Suspects

When the murders occurred, suspicion quickly turned to Janelle Potter, a socially isolated woman with a tumultuous relationship with the victims. Her involvement, along with that of her parents, Marvin “Buddy” and Barbara Potter, cast a shadow of doubt over the case. The family’s insular dynamic created an environment ripe for manipulation and deceit.

The Role of a “CIA Officer”

Things take a bizarre turn with the appearance of a mysterious CIA operative named “Chris.” Supposedly working to protect Janelle, Chris quickly became a central figure in this web of deception. However, the truth behind his identity—and the role he played—was far darker than anyone could have imagined.

Catfishing Gone Awry

Janelle’s elaborate catfishing scheme, carried out through emails and fake messages, became so convincing that it entangled her family and boyfriend, Jamie, into a fabricated story of danger. This narrative eventually spiraled out of control, leading to a devastating loss and a life-altering series of choices.

The Aftermath and the Trials

As the truth began to unravel, those caught in this twisted plot were forced to face the consequences. Buddy Potter received a life sentence for the murders, while Jamie Curd struck a plea deal, serving 25 years. Janelle and her mother were also convicted, each receiving life sentences for their roles in orchestrating the crime.

A Tale of Misguided Loyalty

At the heart of this tragic case lies a story of misguided loyalty and misplaced trust. The damage done was profound—not only for the families affected by the deaths but also for Tyler, who is left to carry the weight of his parents’ legacy and tragic fate.

Join us as we dive deeper into this twisted tale of deception and the devastating ripple effect it left on everyone involved. With every shocking revelation, Super SUS brings you face to face with the darkness that sometimes lurks in the most unexpected places.