Episode 30: Gone Without a Trace – The Disappearance of Brian Shaffer
In our latest episode of Super SUS, we delve into the perplexing case of Brian Shaffer, a second-year medical student at Ohio State University, whose sudden disappearance from a bustling bar on a spring night in 2006 remains an enigma. Join us as we navigate through the mystery that left experts baffled and a family seeking answers.
The Night of Disappearance
Brian was last seen on March 31, 2006, as he ventured out for a night of bar hopping with friends in Columbus, Ohio. The evening started at the quirky-named Ugly Tuna Saloona, where fun and drinks flowed as it was the beginning of spring break. Security footage captured Brian entering the bar, chatting with friends, and stepping outside briefly, but it never showed him leaving. This anomaly has perplexed investigators for years.
A Search with No Answers
Despite exhaustive searches by family, friends, law enforcement, and even divers exploring nearby waters, no trace of Brian was ever found. Theories abound about what may have happened—each with its own set of complexities and questions.
Theories and Speculations
Voluntary Disappearance: Could Brian have decided to start anew, leaving everything behind to escape life's pressures? Loved ones refute this, as he left behind all personal belongings and never reached out, not even after his father's sudden death.
Accidental Death: Many believe Brian may have fallen victim to the hazardous construction site adjacent to the bar. But searches of the area yielded no evidence.
Foul Play: Some suspect a malicious actor may have harmed Brian. Suspicion falls partly on his friend Clint Florence, who refused a polygraph test. Yet, the lack of evidence raises doubts about this theory's credibility.
Suicide or Medical Emergency: Though Brian was seen as upbeat, the stress of recent events might have led to unexpected actions. However, the thorough searches and lack of evidence make this theory speculative at best.
Smiley Face Killer: A fringe theory links his disappearance to a supposed network targeting young men. Experts largely dismiss this due to inadequate evidence.
A Family and Community in Purgatory
Brian's disappearance left his family, particularly his girlfriend Alexis Waggoner and his brother Derek Shaffer, in limbo. Alexis, who anticipated marriage and a future with Brian, was left clinging to memories and unanswered questions.
The mystery of Brian Shaffer remains a haunting puzzle. As we share his story, we also remember the vibrant life he led and the hope that one day answers will emerge. If you have any leads, please reach out to the Columbus Division of Police or submit a tip to Crime Stoppers. Brian's story deserves resolution.
Photos:
